Pensioners could forfeit their entire Winter Fuel Payment if their income exceeds £35,000 by just 1p, highlighting concerns over the ‘cliff edge’ rule introduced alongside the benefit’s reintroduction.
State pensioners could lose the full value of their Winter Fuel Payment if their income goes just 1p over the £35,000 limit, according to Martin Lewis, the MoneySavingExpert founder. The warning comes as the payment has been restored for eligible older people, but the government has kept an income test that can claw back the money in full from higher earners.
Lewis described the rule as a “cliff edge” on his podcast, saying that the system is not tapered. In practice, that means pensioners with income above £35,000 for the tax year do not lose part of the benefit, but all of it. The official government guidance says HMRC will recover the payment either through PAYE tax code changes or via Self Assessment.
The threshold includes state pension income, private pensions, wages and savings interest outside an ISA. Some benefits, including Pension Credit, Personal Independence Payment and Disability Living Allowance, are excluded. That means pensioners receiving the full new state pension have less room than they might expect before reaching the limit once other taxable income is added.
The government says the payment remains £200 for households with someone under 80 and £300 where someone is 80 or older, with recovery applying only where total income exceeds the threshold. MoneySavingExpert has also cautioned pensioners to watch for scams linked to the payment, while HMRC says most people will not need to take any action beyond their normal tax affairs.
Disclaimer: This article is intended to inform and educate, not to recommend or endorse any financial product, investment or strategy. Please consider your own financial circumstances and seek professional advice where appropriate before making financial decisions.
